Joe Quesada made a major error in his Joe Fridays' Q&A with fans on
Newarama when asked by a fan about the Phoenix Limited Series that was never published:
Q: novak- Does Marvel have any plans to finally publish the Phoenix limited series that was written by Chris Claremont and penciled by Rick Leonardi back in 1986? It was frequently mentioned in the letter pages of Uncanny X-Men in 1986 and 1987, leaving many fans greatly disappointed that it never came out.
The pages that have leaked onto the Internet are amazing and fans would love to finally see that series published.
JQ: Novak, I believe this story eventually was printed several years ago in the X-Men: Fast Friends limited series.
Joe Quesada is confusing The Phoenix Limited Series with True Friends, which was also penciled by Rick Leonardi. That was an Excalibur Special that was stopped when Chris Claremont quit Marvel in 1991 and later resurrected when Claremont returned to Marvel in 1999. They are two completely different titles and have absolutely nothing to do with each other.
For more information about it, see the Unpublished Phoenix Limited Series summary page.
Rachel Fans Need to Take Action!
We need to let Joe Quesada and the X-Men editors (Axel Alonso, Nick Lowe and Sean Ryan) know that fans want the Phoenix Limited Series published and we aren't going let Quesada get away with claiming it was.
Please, take some time to do each of the following:
1. Post a reply on the Newarama thread discussing Joe Quesada's erroneous answer to the Phoenix LS question.
2. To make sure Quesada gets the message, post on the Newarama thread with questions for Joe Quesada and ask him if the Phoenix LS will be published.
3. Email the X-Editors at officex@marvel.com requesting that they publish the Phoenix Limited Series.
4. Write to the Marvel Editors at:
X-Mail
c/o Marvel Comics
417 5th Ave
NY, NY 10016
If all of the fans can do a major push here, maybe we can finally get the Phoenix LS to be actually published.
Update! Joe Quesada Responds!Joe Quesada responded to fans telling him that "Fast Friends" is not the Phoenix Limited Series Newarama when asked by a fan about the Phoenix Limited Series that was never published:
JQ: Well, novak, I got to tell you, I've asked around the office and no one can recall or has any knowledge of this story. Help me out here; send me a link to where you've seen these pages and we'll look into it. I wish I could be more helpful here and I'm sorry about giving the wrong answer, but this one has thrown everybody here for a loop, including Ralph Macchio who has been here [shudder] 30 years!
By the way, also the fact that no one can recall this story doesn't bode well for future publication as I would suspect that the entirety of the art and story may have been lost to the winds.
Fans needs to keep emailing officex@marvel.com and demanding the Phoenix Limited Series.
Update #3 - Joe Q Finally Gets a Clue But the Campaign Continues:
In this week's Joe Friday, Joe finally figured out what the Phoenix Limited is, but gave a very disappointing answer.
Q: "Dark Beast" - Re: The Phoenix LS that has been discussed in the last two Joe Fridays.
I posted info about this at CBR well over a year ago (8/7/2005) that featured unfinished penciled pages turned up for the series. I'll repost the info and the links here, maybe that will help jog Marvel's memory on things. CC at least probably recalls the storyline, or at least the jist of it. Hell, he may even still have his script on file somewhere. So it wouldn't be that hard to dust it off.
“I saw this posted over on ComicBoards.Com, and thought you guys would like to take a look at it. It's art by Rick Leonardi from the Chris Claremont's unpublished Phoenix Mini-Series which was announced in the Uncanny X-Men #208 letters page and then scrapped. It was supposed to take place between Uncanny X-Men #209 (when Rachel leaves with Spiral) and the Excalibur Special (where Rachel escapes from the Mojoverse and ends up in London) back in the 80's. There's only three pages up there, but it's nice to see what might have been.
http://www.comicartfans.com/GalleryP...&GCat=0&UCat=0
http://www.comicartfans.com/GalleryP...&GCat=0&UCat=0
http://www.comicartfans.com/GalleryP...&GCat=0&UCat=0
http://img32.imageshack.us/my.php?image=p16wp.jpg
JQ: Just so you folks understand how important your comments and suggestion are here on NJF, we’ve been looking into this since it was first discussed and I think we’ve finally come across the answer. Editor and moonlighting private investigator, Andy Schmidt, did some digging and emailed Rick Leonardi about the project.
According to Rick, the series was going to be written by Chris Claremont and inked by Dan Green. Rick said it dealt with Rachel and her relationship with Franklin Richards and the Power Pack. The going logic at the time was that it got too complicated with past/present/future continuity and was subsequently shelved with I believe less than an issue having been penciled. That’s the whole story, folks, wish I had better news to report but it seems that this project was no where near completion before it was killed.
The campaign needs to continue! Keep contacting the X-Office and asking that the Phoenix Limited Series be finished and published!!
Labels: Campaign